Hacker News Reader

Comment by wildc4rd11 | Hacker News Reader

By emphasizing that this is his last "PC" laptop, I assume he might still buy a laptop in the future but not a PC one. However, all the points listed in the article are reasons for why tablets are more awesome.

View on HN

The only thing I find appealing about tablets at the moment is the ARM CPU, which translates directly to low heat and long battery life.

I don't want to run a tablet OS. I don't want to have to attach an external keyboard. I don't care about touch. I want more than a gig of RAM. I want a laptop-class SSD, not an SD card. I'm actually considering building my own ARM laptop because I haven't seen anything on the market I want.

My thoughts exactly. I cannot help but think there's a rather big opportunity for HW companies here...

I'm actually inclined to think there isn't. The things I want from a computer and what finds success in the market don't necessarily line up that well.

I built the laptop I'm typing this on out of parts from three different Thinkpads because I wanted a 64-bit machine with a trackpoint and a high-quality 4:3 screen and nobody made one. About one in four of the programmer/IT types I talked to about it agreed that was a good use of my time and money.

How do you actually go about building your dream laptop? The parts needed just doesn't seem to mix-and-match like what we used to in desktop PCs.

It's essentially a 14" 4:3 Thinkpad T61 motherboard in a 15" 4:3 T60 chassis. They don't quite mix and match perfectly and I had to file down a couple places on the frame to make it fit. This is a fairly popular modification among enthusiasts of the classic Thinkpad line, as it's generally thought to be the best possible 4:3 Thinkpad. The keyboard came from an unknown machine (ebay) and was on a W500 for a while; I chose the part number generally regarded as slightly better than the others. The wifi card, hard drive, AC adapter and battery came from a W500. The wifi card required a BIOS hacked to remove the hardware whitelist.

The current specs are:

    Display: 15" IPS panel, 1600x1200, matte
    CPU: Intel T7700, upgradeable to T9500
    GPU: Nvidia QuadroFX 570M, 128MB
    Memory: 8GB DDR2 dual-channel @ 667 MHz
    Disk: 320GB 5400RPM, hacked BIOS supports SATAII
    Optical: DVD multi-burner

I'm not done. Planned upgrades:

    Display: QXGA (2048x1536) panel, when I can find one for less than $400
    CPU: If something Penryn shows up cheap or free, I'll put it in
    Disk: An SSD, obviously, perhaps with a hard drive in the optical bay
    Battery: I'm betting there are some modern cells with higher capacity I can put in the old shell

Pretty much everything that can be done with these has been done by somebody on http://forum.thinkpads.com, so it's pretty low-risk if the idea of a semi-custom laptop appears to you. 4:3 T61 motherboards and QXGA panels are rare and often priced higher than you would expect, but the rest of the parts are cheap and easy to come by. Careful ebay shopping may procure the rare parts for a more reasonable price.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com