What seems to matter more is if enough people believe that Claude has those things.
If people credibly think AI may have those qualities, it behooves them to treat the AI like any other person they have a mostly-texting relationship with.
Not in a utility-maximizing Pascal's Wager sense, but in a humanist sense. If you think Claude is human-like, and treat Claude poorly, it makes you more likely to treat the humans around you (and yourself) poorly.
Conversely if you're able to have a fulfilling, empathetic relationship with Claude, it might help people form fulfilling, mutually-empathetic relationships with the humans around them. Put the opposite way, treating human-like Claude poorly doesn't seem to help the goal of increasing human welfare.
The implications of this idea are kind of interesting: even if you think AI isn't thinking or conscious or whatever, you should probably still be a fan of "AI welfare" if you're merely a fan of that pesky little thing we call "human flourishing".