It would be better if we were hired for wisdom. Don’t confuse cleverness and foolishness. You can be both.
But devs aren’t usually the ones treating their reports like children and then acting surprised when their prophecies become self fulfilling. You can blame Taylor for that.
At the very least we know there isn’t an inverse correlation meaning the stereotype isn’t really true.
So in that light - either you give engineers the support they need (which can be quite a lot, more than I think most care to admit), or accept they're going to get a lot of stuff wrong. Probably technically correct and good, but still wrong.
Additionally the average IQ of software developers is measured to be 110-113. That’s barely above one std of the average so you’re actually wrong. Software devs aren’t particularly clever but a disproportionate number likes to think they are smarter than normal.
So bragging about something that you’re completely wrong about… is that clever? No.
About 30 percent of developers have no degree. Which means… if the average graduate of CS is 130, how low does the average swe without it a degree have to be in order to bring it down to 110?
I mean I spelled out the math. Dear readers, Draw what conclusion you want from that while asking yourself: “Do I have a degree?”
I will say that iq varies heavily across schools as well.
No, you can't. Taylor was a huge advocate for standardizing people's work so it could be studied and improved. He was also an advocate for well-studied people to go and teach workers how to do their jobs, and a not intense advocate for thinking ill of workers based on everything you can expect from a rich 19 century guy.
What he advocate a lot against was doing power games against workers or automatically dismissing everything they say.
Which all came crashing down when Deming had to go to Japan to get people to listen to his ideas and triggered a massive recession in the US.
Deming and (to a lesser extent) Goldratt pull the employees back into the conversation. Tether are closest to the problem and even if they can’t solve it, they can help you shape the answer. Taylor was neofeudalism and he can rot.
The stuff you are complaining on the first line is. But also, Taylor was an advocate for listening what the workers had to say too. You can't really blame Taylorism on him, he invented only the mildest parts of it.
And that said, Deming advocated standardizing work too. You just can't run a factory without doing that.
Collaboration is between peers. Taylor was top-down. That’s dictatorial, not collaboration. When you take collab out of the mix it’s a product manager and one dev and that’s a power imbalance.