Equally there is no requirement on ffmpeg to fix these CVEs nor any other.
And, of course, there is no requirement on end-users to run software from projects which do not consider untrusted-input-validation bugs to be high priority.
Equally there is no requirement on ffmpeg to fix these CVEs nor any other.
And, of course, there is no requirement on end-users to run software from projects which do not consider untrusted-input-validation bugs to be high priority.
I see this sort of sentiment daily. The sentiment that only what is strictly legal or required is what matters.
Sometimes, you know, you have to recognise that there are social norms and being a good person matters and has intrinsic value. A society only governed by what the written law of the land explicitly states is a dystopia worse than hell.
Google did more than what is "strictly legal or required", and what they did was submit a good and valid bug report. But for some reason we're mad because they didn't do even more. Why? The world is objectively a better place for having this bug report, at least now people know there's something to address.
The Copenhagen Interpetation of Ethics is annoyingly prevalent (https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/QXpxioWSQcNuNnNTy/...)
That is plainly ridiculous. An orchard without heavy metals is obviously an ideal world in this case, but a world where people are at least informed of the places where the heavy metals are is orders of magnitude better than one where they’re unknowing getting heavy metal poisoning.
If you find yourself with potentially serious security bugs in your repo, then the social norm should be for you to take ownership of that because, well, it's your repo.
The socially unacceptable activity here should be treating security issues as an irritation, or a problem outside your control. If you're a maintainer, and you find yourself overwhelmed by genuine CVE reports, then it might be worth reflecting on the root cause of that. What ffmpeg did here was to shoot the messenger, which is non-normative.
What's this even saying?
Then they're free to fork it and never use the upstream again.