I've decided that the answer (for me) is that Slackware is the craft microbrew of Linux distros. Painstakingly created, tended, and bottled by one man (with some diligent helpers). No, it doesn't have the flashy ad campaigns of the majors, or the ease of (X), but you can tell someone has taken their time with this distro, and crafted it with care and love. Pat V. has a vision, and this is it. That appeals to me in intangible ways that a simple list of the technical 'advantages' of Ubuntu/Arch/etc does not. It's not to everyone's taste, but I don't think it was ever meant to be.