That said, OLPC was extremely ambitious. I don't think they achieved any of the project's objectives. They get a lot of criticism because of that, and it's all ridiculously unfair.
And honestly, if you think that's stupid, I'm not really interested on whatever else you think on the subject. It happened to not work for several reasons, some of them mistakes from the OLPC project, but insisting it's an inevitable result is just uninformed blabber.
There’s one failed program indicating that it didn’t work. Are you aware of any successful programs showing that it could?
Heck, most policymakers in LDCs panned the program at the time as well not actually prioritizing the aid that was needed [2]
[0] - https://econ.berkeley.edu/sites/default/files/Bonds.pdf
[1] - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5859813/
[2] - https://web.archive.org/web/20170210165101/http://edition.cn...
Ever heard of something called a budget?
Teachers, aid workers, doctors, and others need to get paid. Their suppliers need to get paid. Infrastructure needs to be built.
All of that costs money.
My point is simply that the amount of productivity a given population can exercise is not bound to the amount of money in circulation.
It is bound by other constraints.
Wrong.
There is nothing magical about the idea that a resource used for one thing is unavailable to be used for another thing.
> it isn't true in general, where it's parallelized, distributed, discrete and largely independent instead.
Can you provide any concrete example of where the premise does not hold true?
The nature of research is that some things succeed/fail to different degrees than others, and some that have not sufficiently succeeded will in the future, or will inform other successes. If we already knew the answers, it wouldn't be research.
The programs I gave as examples above all had previously been tested in control groups via RCT before they were rolled out en masse. On top of that, these initiatives were done in coordination with local stakeholders.
This is why JPAL@MIT [0] (Banerjee, Duflo) and REAP@Stanford [1] (Liu, Wang, Rozelle) have had significant success in helping raise HDIs in the states in India and China respectively that they worked with.
On top of that, OLPC (and similar initiatives) took a significant amount of oxygen from the philanthropy ecosystem, with programs and initiatives that had a better strike rate being looked over simply because "it's Negreponte". Even Negreponte's MIT Media Lab largely failed from an outcomes perspective, and was buoyed becuase of donor relations.
> done in coordination with local stakeholders
That reminds me of my first impression of OLPC when I first read about it - a typical patronizing rich-world kind of aid, 'let them eat cake'.
I don’t have any insight as to what sort of aid would have been more effective, but quite frankly some of the criticisms were ridiculous when you consider the majority of people in these countries had a cheap mobile phone in their pocket a decade later.
https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2018/10/09/majorities-in-...
OLPC only let you use a computer without internet in a number of areas where broadband and cellphone penetration was nonexistent until the 2010s expansion because of Japanese, Korean, Chinese, and Indian commodity telecom infra.
I was under the impression that these devices were Wi-Fi enabled; I take your point that penetration rates for broadband were nowhere near as high back then, but I still think a lot of the criticisms were misplaced. The penetration of telecomm into these countries is going to have massive upside in the next two decades, and computer literacy plays a part in that. I suspect there are compounding network effects involved here that don’t really exist for linear problems like healthcare (though I could just be underestimating the immediate benefit of $1 in medicine vs. $1 in digital literacy).
Yet internet penetration in Kenya was only 43% [0]. Additionally, countries with significantly higher HDIs (ie. Significantly higher developmental indicators) like Thailand had lower internet penetration in 2014.
Internet penetration was extremely useful in building out infra, but it was just one piece of various other pieces of social infrastructure needed to build human capital.
> The penetration of telecomm into these countries is going to have massive upside in the next two decades, and computer literacy plays a part in that
Most households in developing countries don't have computers [1], so assuming internet penetration implies computer literacy is a fallacy, as most households globally instead use a cellphone as their primary computing device [2].
This is one of the reasons why OLPC failed. Steve Jobs was correct that the smartphone user experience is the best experience for non-technical users.
The organization would have realized this if they tested their hypothesis first, but they didn't. Even Bill Gates called them out for this when they were trying to fundraise in the early 2000s [3]
[0] - https://www.internetlivestats.com/internet-users-by-country/...
[1] - https://datahub.itu.int/data/?e=AGO&i=12046
[2] - https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/IT.CEL.SETS.P2?most_rec...
[3] - https://www.cio.com/article/254451/consumer-technology-bill-...
I was using computer literacy as a stand-in for technical literacy.
> Steve Jobs was correct that the smartphone user experience is the best experience for non-technical users.
We’re speaking about this in retrospect; mass-market smartphones were still in their infancy when the project launched.
> Even Bill Gates called them out for this when they were trying to fundraise in the early 2000s
Gates doesn’t mention anything about smartphones in this article.
https://waack.org/2010/04/27/put-more-computers-outside-the-...
https://www.ted.com/talks/sugata_mitra_kids_can_teach_themse...