Hacker News Reader

Comment by rconti | Hacker News Reader

It always surprises me when people want stop signs in their neighborhood for traffic calming. The last thing I want is all of the noise and pollution of vehicles stopping and starting over and over again; surely various piece of road furniture like bulb-outs, roundabouts, etc, do a better job with fewer drawbacks. Other than cost, of course.

View on HN

My assumption is that stop signs act somewhat as a way to enforce the lower speed limits in residential areas. There's several stretches without stops in my suburb where I've seen drivers whizzing by very obviously above the 25mph speed limit, which is bad enough on its own but becomes a serious hazard when combined with the massive blind spots that come from curbs on both directions being filled to the brim with parked cars.

A better solution would probably be radar-based speed signs with printed threats of fines, though.

> A better solution would probably be radar-based speed signs with printed threats of fines, though.

I don't think people respond to those as much as they do to "traffic calming" like speed bumps, roundabouts, and narrow choke points.

Probably true, but all of those are significantly more involved installations or modifications.

To be clear, I'm all in favor of reworking neighborhood roads to be more friendly to pedestrians, but I think things like signs have a significantly better chance of actually being implemented in most circumstances.

Of course, drivers respond to speed bumps the same way they respond to other poor road surfaces: 3-ton SUVs.

They put one in front of my friend's house. It's a big plastic one almost as big as a speed table. The complainer Karens drive .03mph over it and get honked at or driven around. The trucks and vans, anything driven by an employee or a teenager just speeds right over and a small number of people go for air time. 11/10. Highly entertaining. And this is all in addition to having to listen to every vehicle accelerate after it of course.

Good synergy with those "road-diet" narrow chokepoints then.

>My assumption is that stop signs act somewhat as a way to enforce the lower speed limits in residential areas.

At the expense of basically training people to roll them.

They added a stop sign near me, and now I get to hear the engines rev as they accelerate.

The EVs passing by are nice, though!

There were a number of accidents which prompted the 4 way stop.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com