But blogs and forums should be able to exist.
But blogs and forums should be able to exist.
1. Website was sued over having "defamatory" content posted by a user and website won because they had no moderation (minus illegal stuff).
2. Website was sued over having "defamatory" content posted by a user and website lost because they had moderation (curated to be "family friendly").
Politicians (and less importantly, the general public) like the idea of websites being able to be "family friendly".
So forums and blogs can still exist but if you do any sort of not strictly legally required moderation you have legal liability for all content without 230.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_230#Background_and_pas...
Ah, so this is a way to make us "need" to enshrine moderation opinion into legislation in order to have nice things
It won't even be "turning into Reddit" it's all going to turn into 4chan.
Which means the consequence for any mistake on sticking exactly to the bounds of legally mandatory moderation is enormous liability (either massive civil liability if you go slightly beyond the bounds of the minimum, or given the source of most minimums catastrophic criminal liability if you fall below it); the only realistic approach at non-trivial scale is just not to allow UGC except at the level you are willing to edit as if it were first party content you were going to be fully responsible for.
Exciting times. It will be interesting to see how this all shakes out.