Twitter: It’s time for patent trolls to bear the costs of frivolous lawsuits
gigaom.com
gigaom.com
Truly frivolous legal actions (on which everyone agrees) aren't tried, they're cast out in preliminary hearings.
> After a trial before a jury, we managed to prove that we didn’t infringe and that the asserted claims from the patent were invalid.
Invalidating a patent in court doesn't make the proceeding frivolous -- all the plaintiff needs to do is claim that he sincerely believed in the patent and in his claims. A frivolous proceeding is one in which a plaintiff knowingly and deliberately wastes the court's time with actions that have no substance.
Also, to base a judgment about frivolousness on the outcome of a trial is to suggest that all losing plaintiffs are acting frivolously on the basis of the outcome.
Don't get me wrong -- I think the present patent system stinks to high heaven. But trying to call some patent proceedings "frivolous" just won't work.
What needs to change is not how the law is enforced, but the law itself.