Agreed, but if MS shares with the right 'limited audience', it could work out OK. If they have Facebook, Twitter, Instagram (still looks doubtful), a few more big names and a few major games, >80% of users will be fine. Us techies won't be, of course.
Don't get me wrong- this still seems like a weird move from MS. But I don't think it leaves them "teetering on the edge of failure".