But the topic of the rant was both how "online video has been solved" and "it's such a shame that Youtube won online video". He obviously hopes for a day soon when there are 5 or more places to go for video online that have equal market share... That will never happen.
Not saying Youtube will be King forever, but fragmented markets are not stable except if there are other forces at play (like government regulation, language, or massive costs to switch providers).
It seems that we as a society like having a homogeneous environment more than a heterogeneous one for most things. I wonder if there are any academic studies that show that?
My theory is this: in this online world we live in, where there are no geographic boundaries any more, we need to have some common references when talking. Take Twitter for example - what if there were 10 other sites like Twitter and they all had equal market share? How do you get the updates from all your friends? All your friends would have to join the same one. And so worldwide, one site would grab the most market share. It HAS to be that way.
Or for video, let's say I create a short video clip, and upload it to 5 different video sites. Now my community is fragmented, and my fan base is divided. Eventually, one site gives me slightly more comments, slightly more traffic, slightly more shares, and then that becomes the best site to use for my type of video and I give more attention to that site. My fans go to that site as well because it has the best and most active conversation about my videos. So there has to be a favorite site for videos.
Not saying that you can't have a site for very specific niches. Like funny videos can be on FunnyOrDie, while Hollywood movies can use Netflix, realtime streaming can be Ustream... but people need to know where the one place to go for the content they are interested in. I think it has to be that way.
Can anyone think of a fragmented online business with no outside influence that keeps it that way? The only one I can think of is "online email", but the costs of changing your email address (time and hassle wise) is enormous so switching is not easy.
It's hard to explain, but to me it makes sense that in each market there is a clear leader and it requires a monumental effort to go to a new leader.
[edited for bad grammar and clarification]