Hacker News Reader

Comment by dagmx | Hacker News Reader

The modules are just inset usb-c dongles.

Handy that you can have them fully encased but there’s nothing really limiting any other laptop on this front. You just use an external dongle and have the same flexibility.

Maybe some people really want the enclosed module so they have fewer things to carry, but that’s a pretty small advantage that I’m not sure many people will value.

I could get something like this ( https://satechi.net/products/undefined/products/pro-hub-slim ) for my MacBook Air and come out ahead on weight and size.

View on HN

>but there’s nothing really limiting any other laptop on this front. You just use an external dongle and have the same flexibility.

Yeah, but thars another part to lose. I have tons of dongles and expansion bays, and have lost half a ton of them to the tides of school, work, travel, and carelessness. Most lost, some break because it's a huge portrusion out of your core machine. A few borrowed and never returned. One of them stuck at an office I got laid off from but never returned to post pandemic (but the severance hush money was worth more than me raising a fuss as opposed to replacing the $30 bay).

I don't need it to literally be plug and play, but I appreciate a more modular setup that is flush and stuck to the machine.

PS. Your link is 404.

Ah weird the link didn’t work. It looks like their site overrides the url that is set for link sharing.

This one should work, copied it from the address bar instead.

https://satechi.net/products/pro-hub-slim?variant=4019950983...

In wish I could have lived for a month or two with the Framework system to get a better feeling of it.

I'm usually either docked at my primary desk and only need a single USB-C, or moving from place to place and need 2 USB-A and a full size SD reader. I imagine the nice part with the insets is they're flushed so they'less surface to hit when moving the machine around.

I'd actually love to make my own insets that bakes the wireless dongles in them, that sounds doable.

If you have a 3D printer you can print enclosures https://www.printables.com/model/139879-framework-laptop-exp...

https://github.com/LeoDJ/FW-EC-DongleHiderPlus?tab=readme-ov...

I've yet to build one, but this project looks very interesting in that regard.

> You just use an external dongle and have the same flexibility

And with thunderbolt, you get to have one dongle-sized dock, that connects with one cable, and gives you the full gamut of ports. I really love being able to connect 1 cable when I get to my desk, and have multiple monitors, all peripherals, plus power cable instantly.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com