If you own a house in the middle of the woods, you bear all the risk for the quality of your renter. If you live in a condo building, the other tenants are exposed to that risk. In the former case, I can totally control the level of risk I'm exposed to based on my choices of who I host. In the latter case, if I'm a fellow tenant, I have no control over that risk. The AirBnB host in my building might only choose tenants with 100+ reviews, or they may choose tenants with no reviews.
I would suggest trying AirBnB a little and looking at what the people who actually use the service are like first without worrying about some kind of imagined stranger danger.
My point is that as a tenant in a building with an AirBnB host, I have absolutely zero guarantees about what kind of tenants AirBnB hosts take on. Maybe some need the money and are willing to take on people with no reputation scores? I'm willing to trust my building management to take responsibility for screening tenants because if they fail I can sue them and I know they can pay because they are insured.
That's the point you keep dancing around. AirBnB's reputation system might be great. That's irrelevant to me as a tenant in the same building. I don't get to see or have any control over the reputations scores of the people AirBnB hosts in my building take on. The AirBnB host exposes me to a level of risk, he is in total control over that level of risk, and he doesn't carry insurance against that risk. That is a harm to me.
Not really, my point was with respect to who cares for their property the most: owners > long term renters > short term( 1 week or less) renters