Half Of Great Barrier Reef Lost Over Past 27 Years
singularityhub.com
singularityhub.com
However seeing a colorful reef turning grey is depressive on Sunday and partially explains my mood to get voted down.
Environmental news do not spark lively discussions here
Well... some do - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4244787There are places to go for this kind of news and here ain't it.
But regardless, the story made it to the front page so obviously enough people felt it was relevant.
Of these, only the bleaching is a mostly direct cause of civilization. But reading the last paragraph, apparently coastal pollution increases the starfish growth:
> "But is there really any hope of slowing the Crown-of-thorns? While the adult Crown-of-thorn feeds on coral polyps, its larvae feed on phytoplankton. Phytoplankton, in turn, multiply in the presence of fertilizers and other man-made pollutants commonly found in coastal runoff. Simply by decreasing pollution in these areas would benefit coral growth."
Apparently, removing the starfish would have a recovering effect on the reef:
> "The study shows that in the absence of Crown-of-thorns, coral cover would increase at 0.89 percent per year, so even with losses due to cyclones and bleaching there should be slow recovery"
We should take care not to kill off one species to save another, though. The starfish are very widely spread than the reef, but any intervention should still be carefully considered.
- it is a meta-study based on surveys performed more frequently on damaged areas, by poorly trained observers
- it asserts storm damage is increasing because of increased cyclone intensity, but there is no measured increase in intensity
- the cause and effect of water quality issues are significantly more complicated than presented
It also raises the question of what benefit Australia has received from all its previous GBR management investment. If efforts of previous decades have been so completely ineffectual, why throw more money at it?
Not saying that his criticisms are wrong, but it sounds like if anyone were going to wave off bad news about the GBR and say 'oh it's fine, don't worry,' it'd be him.
HN has its fair share of people like that.
what I would like is perspective - a top down weekly update that works as a complete model - sort of the earth sim in SnowCrash - but for the most important changes - wars, famines, vast new investments, politics and economic pressures.
Something that says each week, the great barrier reef has halved but it ranks only 27th behind ...
http://www.economist.com/node/21564620
http://www.economist.com/node/21564618
And the economist did cover this news more thoroughly:
And then the article describes Maps, a major business component that is not Internet search at all.
Also, nice aptonym on Dr De'ath studying coral reef death.
I am asking / wanting an explicit model - for example the Treasury in UK govt runs very comprehensive economic modelling software - trying to gauge for example the impact of floods on productive capacity on semiconductors.
Now if you could run such sims on a wiki like basis - that the oil consultancy in Houston could accept inputs and provide outputs and run a more sophisticated model than the base case then there would be a base model to refer to - to help gauge what is more important. And that decision would rest on what you called more important (lives, standards of living etc). And on which models/ plugins you choose - the left wing oil consultancy or the right wing oil consultancy
Basically newspapers tell human interest stories, and the guiding models for that (editor taste and opinion) seems to have dimmed into A/B tested celeb output.
I would like - well, perspective, context and then news