And my "reasoning" is pretty much like a long ChatGPT verbal and sometimes not-so-verbal (visual) conversation with myself.
If my mind really did abstract platonic thinking I think answers to hard problems would just instantly appear to me, without flaws. But only problems I hve solved before and can pattern match do that.
And if I have to think any new thoughts I feel that process is rather similar to how LLMs work.
It is the same for history of science really -- only thoughts that build small steps on previous thoughts and participate in a conversation actually are thought by humans.
Totally new leaps, which a "platonic thinking machines" should easily do, do not seem to happen..
Humans are, IMO, conversation machines too...