Actually IDEs vs vim are a perfect analogy because they both have the ability to feel like they're helping a tonne, and at the end of the work day neither group outperforms the other
I'm not standing on the sidelines criticizing this stuff. I'm using it. I'm growing more and more skeptical because it's not noticably helping me deliver features faster
At this point I'm at "okay record a video and show me these 3x gains you're seeing because I'm not experiencing the same thing"
The increased demand for rigor is because my experience isn't matching what others say
I can see a 25% bump in productivity being realistic if I learn where it works well. There are people claiming 3-10x. It sounds ridiculous