I seriously hope HN discourse has the bare minimum of “open the link and read it before commenting”.
What happens a lot, at least for me, is that people will start reading the comments to see if they want to bother reading the link. Then they might start commenting on what's already been said. It's easy to slip into that pattern.
Though you also frequently see top-level comments that appear to be based on the headline alone.
The number of people who actually read the entire article and then attempt to comment in good faith are few and far between.