I thought I agreed with you at first but I'm not sure. Either we disagree on how important what and why are, or on how "why" is the defined or expressed.
I think commit messages should actually have a concise "what" in them.
I frequently enough end up looking at git log trying to sort out what changed (to track down a bug or regression), and based on the commit message, do a git show to see what the actual diffs are.
So in that context, at least, knowing what changed in a commit is actually quite useful, and why is arguably less so.
I suspect my idea of "what" and your idea of "why" overlap in this scenario.
Edit: and after typing all that, I realized your comment doesn't imply there shouldn't be a "what" described anyway so maybe I'm just discussing nothing at all.