So, the answer is to take away their money? That seems morally wrong somehow...
Nothing is being stolen from another person. Instead, the schism network's users will be protected from being robbed in the future by early adopters who possess a great many coins without having placed any dollars, gold, etc. into the exchanges.
Yes, my solution is in some ways harsh and inelegant, but if you don't like it, you should be prepared to deal with the Great Bitcoin Flood once Satoshi and friends finally decide to cash out. Or avoid Bitcoin entirely.