I love Steam, but they don't police it as much as you think.
First off, pre-orders are always problematic as Steam doesn't know if a new game is going to be good or an unfinished tech demo that was released one year too early, which was the case for a game I pre-ordered last year. If it's bad enough they'll do refunds, but you need to push them and they won't always grant them if you don't ask in a timely manner.
More troubling, they sell games that they know are broken. Full Spectrum Warrior is one example that I can think of. The game tries to resolve a no-longer existing address hundreds of times a second and lags horribly. It's easily fixed but Steam support doesn't care because it's not Valve's game.
Steam does a lot of things right, but it's very much a buyer beware situation, and for higher stakes than a $0.99 app.