I see the same point when it comes to fiction writing. Tested (via duck.ai) a while ago with creating fiction stories in less than 500 characters and it came up with generics and repeats that even went above the limit.
Tried again just now with 5o mini, and although it waxed poetically, there were cracks and gaps, still felt rather generic, and certainly failed at twists and humour.
It can write about a spark, but the content has no spark.