There are interesting aspects to the data, but they overstate what the numbers they present tell us about inequality.
There are interesting aspects to the data, but they overstate what the numbers they present tell us about inequality.
In a rich country this might mean paying for childcare so you can work. Your expenditure has gone up, but you are only better off by the increased post tax income less the cost of childcare. Even worse is paid childcare has substituted for family provided (e.g. grandparents) childcare.
In a poor country it might mean buying food instead of growing it. An industrial worker will buy their food, a subsistence farmer will grow their own. There is a huge increase in expenditure, but they might well end up with a worse diet.
This is not new. The initial workforce for the industrialisation of Britain (the first country to industrialise) was available because of the enclosure of common land forced people to seek work in cities.
That's a pretty clear illustration of the myopia of excessively quantitative economic thinking. The economist looks at easily-quantified numbers: WAGES - CHILDCARE_EXPENSE = POSITIVE_NUMBER, and concludes "PROFIT! EVERYONE WINS!" But the hard-to-quantify negatives are completely ignored: the poorer relationship between the kids and parents, negative psychological effects on the kids due to day care, etc. That's especially true when talking about things in aggregate.
My point is that people are not even as much financially better off as the numbers say.
That is why billionaires typically give money away by putting it in foundations they control (so they keep the power) rather than just giving it to poor people (which would be more effective as people could spend it on what they most need).
He saw capitalism as a natural and necessary step before developing communism.
Hence why most criticism of soviet and Chinese communism is fundamentally flawed, since they tried to develop communism in feudal societies.
FWIW I am libertarian leaning, but it is obvious to me capitalism has obvious defects that must be either compensated for, or be done away with entirely.
Not to fall into the "communism is when free stuff" trope, but...
Most people like public schools, public roads, public transit, public parks, and public libraries.
The benefits of public goods are well known. This is the whole field of public finance economics.
Market failures are also well-known. Negative externalities, moral hazard, adverse selection etc. Hence carbon taxes, congestion charges, and universal healthcare.
In other words, sometimes free trade capitalism works, other times it doesn't, and it's not a mystery when. Marx's whole spiel about contradictions is wrong and largely throws the baby out with the bath water, so to speak.
As for Marx "spiel about contradictions", all he did was take capitalists seriously on the notion that competition in a truly free market will tend to drive down margins once the market is fully exploited.
One can certainly disagree with his conclusions over the consequences of that - e.g. whether societies will succeed in continuing to mitigate the negative effects, or end up in crises, but the core theory of Marx on capitalism was that competition and markets works as advertised.
And by socialist system with a free market do you mean one where private ownership of the modes of production remains legal, but simply isn't chosen, or do you consider banning private ownership compatible with free markets?
I would consider public ownership but not state ownership compatible with free markets. The only essential element for free markets is competition with sufficiently low regulation. Some socialist ideologies are inherently incompatible with markets, some are not. E.g. libertarian Marxism and other form of libterian socialism are, because they reject centralised government entirely.
i do want to live in the world where money doesn't dictate _consumption_ as much as power. money has to mean something, and its good that it goes into power more than consumption. that means the poor can have a dignified life to buy what they want but they don't get to dictate how money will be allocated.
Why?
Owning a lot of wealth says little about how effectively you can wield power or whether you'll use said power to benefit all or just yourself.
The point is that the unspent income has significant value.
I earn a multiple of the UK median. Above a lower multiple of the median, the primary increased value I got out of earning more was the freedom to stop thinking about what an increasing subset of things cost. I still need to think about what my housing cost, but I don't know what most groceries cost, because it doesn't matter to me.
The mental cost of detail budgeting, planning, and saving for most smaller costs, as well as the associated anxiety, is something I never want to pay again.
My actual spending thus tells a flawed story about the advantage I have over someone earning less.