My mother has a dumbphone. My girlfriend has a Blackberry. My friends have Androids. Some of my coworkers have iOS devices, but not nearly the majority. So, for me, iMessage isn't free. And I think this is true for the majority of the population that doesn't live in the Apple-centred SV hype bubble. If Apple opened the iMessage protocol to non-iOS devices[1], I'd use iMessage in a heartbeat--I prefer its UX. But until then, I'll only use it to reply when someone sends me an SMS--because, like email, SMS is universal.
[1] They wouldn't even have to write iMessage apps for those devices--just allow, say, WhatsApp, to use the iMessage protocol.