I'm surprised that the benchmarks for the Momentus XT are so good, especially since it only has 4 GB (8 for the newer model) of SSD. It would seem that in theory it would be better to just add 4 or 8 GB of DRAM to your main system, but apparently the drive only caches non-sequential data that isn't likely to be read quickly from the platters. I'm thinking of trying one on my aging MacBook Pro.
Anyway the Apple approach should be better because of the bigger SSD and more intelligent caching available at the OS level.