Hacker News Reader

Comment by nradov | Hacker News Reader

Illegal? Seriously? What specific crimes did they commit?

Frankly I don't believe you. I think you're exaggerating. Let's see the logs. Put up or shut up.

The best example I can offer is that when given a marketing goal, a subagent recommended hacking the point-of-sale systems of the customers to force our ads to show up where previously there would have been native network served ads. To do that, assuming we accepted its recommendation, would be illegal. My email is on my profile.

Do you think that AI has magic guardrails that force it to obey the laws everywhere, anywhere, all the time? How would this even be possible for laws that conflict with eachother?

Fraud is a real thing. Lying or misrepresenting information on financial applications is illegal in most jurisdictions the world over. I have no trouble believing that a sub-agent of enough specificity would attempt to commit fraud in the pursuit of it's instructions.

Do you believe allegations of criminal behavior based on zero reliable evidence? I hope you never end up on a jury.

Yes, I believe a person on a hacker forum who has said, through their own evaluations, that they have observed LLM driven agents exhibiting illegal behavior, such as when they have asked an agent to complete certain tasks with what sounds like abstracted levels of context. I believe them because I know I can get an agent to do that myself by simply installing OpenClaw and telling it to apply for as many mortgage loans as possible at the best rate possible.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com