> “Of course not!” thundered the surgeon. “That would have doomed half of the patients to death!”
> Stunned silence filled the lecture hall, and the student softly asked,
> “Which half?”
damn that was good
> “Of course not!” thundered the surgeon. “That would have doomed half of the patients to death!”
> Stunned silence filled the lecture hall, and the student softly asked,
> “Which half?”
damn that was good
yes, exactly that?
it's a parable about null hypothesis - without data to compare against we have no idea whether new procedure is actually any good (as in, better)
in reality conversation would (should) soon turn towards observations by other surgeons, general death rate of the disease or even some basic theory - but simply saying "they would've died, trust me bro" is not it
also note that surgeon is overreacting. "set aside" does not automatically mean "do nothing" - control group should probably be given previous accepted version of treatment, as that's what the new idea is trying to replace