In principle I agree with what you're saying but Torquebox has been something I've had to constantly work on whereas Passenger has always been, more or less, deploy and forget.
I've been using Torquebox since version 2.0.1 (not that long really) but I've never really had a completely stable server. Deployment has always been somewhat of a hassle and recently the HA cache has been so broken that I have not been able to use torquebox in a cluster.
In the end, I'm just happy to have another option. The more the merrier.