Everything you’ve listed, both criticisms and hype, have been true ever since these tools were introduced. I don’t recall a single week going by without reading takes of it being a bubble or replacing everyone.
I mean to say that a year ago there was talk on forums of "fear of AI replacing developers" but companies were not losing 20/30% in one day because of this.
Now, besides talking about it among nerds, the situation is having a real impact in the economic/financial world.