A subscription to something like Longform - curated stories of interest to me. For $5 per month I'd like to have ad free versions of the stories, with better than normal styling.
So the current reason you aren't happy with Longform are the ads and the styling?
But I'm happy to pay for great content. I think that's a clear signal to producers to keep making great content. Until micropayments are sorted and I can pay each different newspaper for every article I read I guess it'd make sense for users to pay the aggregator who then pays the papers based on article read rates.
There's some thorny problems there to be sorted out.
The styling thing is mostly my personal preference; I like big san-serif dark fonts on a light yellow (#ffffcc) background. I use browser plugins at the moment.