Hacker News Reader

The way that I read it would be that the iPhone could definitely be patented. However apps in an app store could not.

So you could have something like the slide to unlock patent. It could bind software shipped as part of the base operating system. But app developers could implement that same feature in an app and be fine.

Far from perfect. But a definite improvement.

View on HN

The way I understand his idea is that a phone is a general purpose computer. If Apple wants to patent slide-to-unlock, they can only patent a hardware implementation (i.e. a chip that only does slide-to-unlock, which is clearly a ridiculous idea).

Then I can come along and write software for Android that implements slide-to-unlock, and I am not infringing because my implementation is software only.

The end result of this means that Apple's slide-to-unlock patent would become worthless.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com