This shouldn't be counter-intuitive. The whole point of octane is to make the fuel less flammable.
Yeah, but that's not how oil companies sell their product. The average consumer has no idea that octane is the description of a specific molecule. They're conditioned to believe that more expensive means better, and the oil companies certainly aren't going to cut their bottom line in order to properly educate consumers.
Absolutely, and I applaud CBC for running an article on it because it is a common misconception that ends up costing a lot of people a whole lot of money.