If you read the chat log he posted, it actually makes him look bad more than anyone else. Yes, it's bad, shady practice to require someone to call you to get a refund you promise, especially if you don't list that they have to call you anywhere.
But again, looking at the chat log, the 99 Designs guy is very apologetic and helpful and Andrew immediately says "OK, I think I'll blog about this and post it to Hacker News and see what everyone else thinks." (This is in response to "Justin" from 99 Designs apologizing for the inconvenience of requiring a phone call).
Hacker News is not your personal soapbox.