Part of the problem with any business with a localization aspect is that it takes more people to get buyin. Yelp in the bay area? Fabulous. Yelp in Louisiana? Not so great. Same goes for meetup.com, where I can find people in my area, as compared to plazes, where there was maybe 1 other person near me.
Yes, people probably won't pay for services who tell them where their current friends are, but there's still value. I personally would be interested in knowing where my "facebook friends" are - for me that's people who I am acquainted with but necessarily socialize with unless it's convenient, like if I'm shopping and want to go see a movie in 10 minutes. Random people who might be interesting are also a way to pass the time if I'm bored waiting for a train.