i don't disagree but you're arguing past the parent comment; public domain is a legal concept that is not universally applicable to the relevant ethics here
Yes. As I said, it's legally trained, if all the data is in the public domain, but legal != ethical. I think the current legal defence of modern LLMs is that it's transformative so copyright doesn't apply, and I certainly wouldn't call them ethical
Do you think the concept of public domain is not ethical?