Sure, and I'm not trying to imply the RethinkDB guys are writing shoddy code or anything. For all I know the thing is bug-free with fantastic performance, perfect linear scaling with both number of cores and number of nodes in the cluster, and really does let you run your analytic workload on the same cluster you're taking transactions on (though I really doubt this last one – running analytics on your transactional database tends to slow transaction latency to a crawl).
That said, with a name like RethinkDB, I guess I expect more than a feature list I could have reasonably put together three years ago and gone, yeah, that's straightforward to do.
I've written my own database (and continue to improve it), so I'm pretty familiar with the issues involved. You're absolutely right that many of these JSON database have serious problems under load with their clustering abilities (and it's always under load, they tend to work fine on simple workloads).
Perhaps RethinkDB can carve out a niche for reliability-under-load among the existing JSON DB field. That's got to be worth something.