The difference is that there will be consequences to their actions; they and the majority of the country will suffer. With that precedent, would it be likely that it would happen again?
From my impression, the main goal tends not to be whether they can come out of this with a much better system instead its how the they can reduce the amount of damage that will be done.
I don't think these people should care about destroying legacies (a company shouldn't be sacred just because it's old, that's pointless sentimentalism), but it seems that they would care about losing a serious amount of money, so the obvious conclusion is that they see themselves losing more in the bailout (the article says as much).
The important question is: do we believe them (they are pretty good with money, after all), or do we try it another way? I personally think we should try it another way, but (from my current relatively comfortable observation post) that's probably more out of curiosity than any reasoned belief.
Both approaches involved regular people "bending over", either through a bad economy or through taxes/inflation.
(I'm trying to avoid a free market vs government debate and provide a contrarian perspective to the article.)
Arguing for an action that will bankrupt you because you think you'll rise out of the ashes like a Phoenix? Seems pretty close to me.
But you're right, that was a bit lame of me to reach for.
A martyr complex is simply a psychological need to suffer for a cause. If I'm wrong about that, let me know why, seriously.
I wasn't arguing that the bailout means no bending over; I would hope that there was still plenty of that, just for the right people. I'd prefer it be the executive who ran his company into the ground and is now scared shitless of living on 500k a year, rather than my neighbor with 2 kids who lost his job b/c of said executive's incompetence.
But maybe you're right, maybe everyone's going to end up with it. We'll see.
Falling housing prices are not an example of losing money. They are an example of losing potential money, since there is no actual loss until sold. That's simplified--interesting things happen with valuation, property taxes, exotic mortgages, etc.
Edit: removed redundant paragraph.
As someone who dodged the housing deflation (not because I'm a genius, but because I got strangely lucky) by getting out before the value went south and moving to a rental at an attractive price as new lots started to idle in my area, I am sympathetic to what you're suggesting, though.
Housing prices were not artificially inflated. They may have been inflated, but there's nothing artificial about the fact that the demand side of the equation was willing to pay the high rates. Everyone agrees the housing prices were inflated, but I'd suggest it was a feedback loop involving government policy, a need for financial institutions to create value w/o necessarily creating wealth for competitive reasons and a desire on the part of investors to turn a profit on a sky-rocketing asset without a full understanding of the reasoning and the risk involved. I might be missing some factors. But I do generally dislike everyone who calls in to C-SPAN in the morning suggesting that only one thing they already happened to dislike for some specific reason was the culprit.
Well, considering that during the time that housing prices increased there was a large mortgage interest deduction, an implicit bailout of Fannie/Freddie, a huge capital gains tax loophole on selected home sales, as well as a variety of programs designed to allow people who wouldn't normally have been able to afford a house to buy one, I'd beg to differ.
The above are all demand stimulating laws. For some reason people believe that paying interest to a bank (instead of rent to a landlord) is the American dream, and significant government revenue was allocated to creating home ownership.
Why wouldn't any smart speculator double down on the idea that by betting on home prices increasing he's got the government on his side and stands to make a mint?
Now, those speculators (and in this group I include anyone who bought a house expecting it to increase faster than twice the rate of inflation) are being bailed out by the policymakers who made their gambles possible!
And I'm not defending the sequence of inanities that led up to this whole debacle. Voted you up, too, because I think the conversation about renting versus interest is a good one. I sold my house about half a year before the collapse and have a sweet rental at the moment.
I suspect that you're having a go at the investors in this comment. Your suggestion that they 'capture' the money 'out of the .. system' is flawed, because wealth is not a zero-sum game. Creating wealth doesn't mean that you're taking it off someone else. Certainly that's the case in the dynamics of investment.
However, your comment could be read as a pithy attack on powerful governments who took us into this mess and are using the chaos created to further their reach into it, and if that's what you meant - touche!