False. The language design safe by default, something that you can confirm super easily doing just the Rust tutorials and compare the same with C or C++.
Read the repo well:
cve-rs implements the following bugs in safe Rust:
Use after free
Buffer overflow
Segmentation fault
NOT REFUTE IT.> There are unsafe blocks all over the stdlib
Unsafe blocks is not the same that unsafe code. Are marked areas that are required to do escape automated checks, and there, you are at the level of a C/C++ programmer (where in that languages ALL THE CODE IS MARKED UNSAFE).
If you complaint against that, is the same as complaint against ALL THE CODE writer on C/C++.
---
One thing important to understand about Rust: Rust is a system language and SHOULD be able to implement everyting including, Buffer overflow, Use after free , Segmentation fault and such. You should be able to implement a terrible OS, malware, faulty drivers, etc, minimally because that is required to test safe programs!
(example: Deterministic Simulation Testing https://turso.tech/blog/introducing-limbo-a-complete-rewrite...).
But what Rust gives is that not assume that you want to do it for most programs.
Physics is unsafe. Something, somewhere needs to provide the safe core.
> And concurrency safety would need to get rid of their blocking IO, which they haven't even acknowledged.
Is your position that blocking IO can't be compatible with concurrency safety? That's a strange claim. Can you explain?
No, that's common knowledge. I fixed concurrency safety by forbidding blocking IO. Others also. Maybe there are other ways, but never heard of other ways.
This seems like a non-sequitur to me? The presence/absence of a GC is not dispositive with respect to determining "safety", especially when the GC itself involves unsafe code.
Just not the cheaters: Rust, Java (until recently), and of course Javascript with its unsafe implementations.
Memory safety bug in a proper lisp? Unheard of, unless you break the GC or do wrong FFI calls.
- The presence of a GC doesn't guarantee memory safety since there are sources of memory unsafety that GCs don't/can't cover (i.e., escape hatches and/or FFI), not to mention the possibility of bugs in the GC implementation itself.
- The absence of a GC doesn't preclude memory safety since you can "just" refuse to compile anything which you can't prove to be memory-safe modulo escape hatches and/or axioms and/or FFI (and bugs, unfortunately). Formal verification toolchains for C (Frama-C, seL4's setup, etc.) and Ada/SPARK's stricter modes are good examples of this.
In the case of Rust:
- `unsafe` blocks (or at least their precursors) were added in 2011 [0].
- Rust's reference-counting GC was removed in 2014 [1].
That's why I think "ripped out their GC" is a bit of a non-sequitur for "got rid of the safeties". Rust wasn't entirely safe before the GC was removed because `unsafe` already existed. And even after the GC was removed, the entire point of Rust's infamous strictness is to reject programs for which safety can't be proved (modulo the same sources that existed before the GC was removed), so the removal of GC does not necessarily imply losing memory safety either.