Hacker News Reader

I'm not familiar with the details of real software development, so I don't know why it's not possible to just "not give the SVG part of the code internet access" or "perform sanitization on post-decoding (url, hex, etc) data".

Is it because the SVG parser/renderer being used is an entire library, and it would be prohibitive to write your own SVG parser/renderer or insert your own code into the existing one?

View on HN

Some of the suggestions are kind-of exactly that. But they specify not a change to the default behavior, but a new behavior based on the presence of a new attribute.

You could change the default behavior to the “safer” behavior. And then add some sort of “danger mode” attribute. But… devs are usually hesitant to do something that would break legitimate code, such as changing the default behavior would do.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com