Things like this are why the Valley's so important. You'd think someone somewhere else would have done this, but noooooo. You just know that if someone else had done this, they'd have tried to make a buck on it. This is a completely altruistic move on YC's part - hell, they're setting up additional competition for the YC program.
But that's no argument against it, or saying it's not important; just that perhaps getting a few more people investing is not going to fix the economy overnight.
10,000 investors invest 10,000 dollars each is 100 million dollars. You could vary that to 1,000 investors doing 100,000 of investment each. 1,000 investors each doing a million dollars would be 1 billion dollars. What relationship do those random numbers bear to reality? Has YC even spent a million dollars on all the companies involved? And there are several people investing in YC, so I think it probably comes out to less than a million a head, and they've been doing this for a while now.
The real impact of startups is not likely going to be in hiring in any case, but still, it's worth looking at some numbers to get an idea of the order of magnitude that we're talking about.
We need to add another 100 ghost founders to account for the extra $5,000, so that makes it: ~350 founders x $5,000/founder = ~$1.75 million invested, so far.
Y Combinator has (I personally believe, but do not necessarily know to be true) additionally sunk capital investment into:
* Beans and rice
* A building and associated land in Boston
* A building and associated land in Mountain View
* Utility bills
* Travel expenses
* Legal fees (including 102 incorporation-fee packages)
* Accounting fees
* Misc.Was there something incorrect, or otherwise objectionable, about this comment?
http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2009/01/twenty-two-years-of-job-crea...
Most hacks take a few years to really show their impact, but somebody's gotta do it, or we'll be in a depression forever.
That doesn't mean it won't lead to good things, I'm just skeptical of a smallish conference in terms of "saving the economy". I don't think that's really it's purpose in any case.
http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2007/09/dayint...
It bears repeating that I'm not knocking what you guys are doing - quite the contrary, I think the best thing most of us can do is just do what we do, well, and hope for the best. I just don't think that your conference will do all that much to get the US economy going again, nor should it be expected to.
Edit. Whatever, people, if you think that PG and company are going to single handedly have more of an effect than billions of dollars in taxes or tax cuts or infrastructure spending or GM failing or more banks going under, or China selling their dollar assets, or whatever, you're welcome to your beliefs, I'm done arguing the point.