Do We Need a New Internet?
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Less spam? Freedom to choose weak passwords for my ebay account? Avoiding a multi hour internet outage once every few years? Allow the military to save money on computer security? Are these the Pearl Harbors and Maginot Lines the article talks about? Exuse me, but were people not dying in the millions during the second world war?
This coalition of computer security "experts" and sensationalist journalists, both with massive vested interests, has been pounding us with this nonsense for decades now. It's boring and stupid and I wish they would just go away and stop threatening my freedom.
Possibly it might be nice to have a service where you can get your gpg key connected with your person. Then you have the ability to sign electric documents and such naught. I do believe this type of option needs to be a private industry and completely optional.
Conversely, complete identification on the Net won't necessarily slow the spread of worms; if you're absolutely certain that you're getting owned by John Smith's computer... you're still getting owned. Even if Microsoft implements extensive forensic logging, at best you could track a worm back to "patient zero" in a dorm room in Whereverstan.
It probably is time to rethink the problem of spammers and worms at a more fundamental level.
But when will enough people come to value such access that all the sites/servers I want to talk to get on that same theme and guarantee that they (or their networks) don't get DoS'd, etc.?
Is it maybe time to change laws that currently make it illegal (even for gov. & gov-sanctioned contractors) to intervene in infected/botted machines? We currently require treatment for carriers of resistant TB to roam freely without treatment. Are not the bot-zombies the technological equivalent?
There already exists systems that authenticate known people - credit cards, for example. So it's at least doable. I wish credit card people opened their infrastructure for authentication as well as payment.
I do think this is largely the browser vendor's fault. Create physical tokens (cert on a usb stick, perhaps) and allow people to have real identity on the web (when you want it.)
Not really true. https is good enough to buy things online. It's better than giving your credit card to a waiter.