This whole Sinofsky drama is a really good lesson for everyone. Nobody is indispensible. Microsoft will be fine without Sinofsky.
This whole Sinofsky drama is a really good lesson for everyone. Nobody is indispensible. Microsoft will be fine without Sinofsky.
Either what you say is right – Microsoft is fine – or what you say is wrong and Microsoft has a bleak future. We don't knkow why Sinofsky left, but to play devil's advocate:
What if Sinofsky did do a good job of working with other executives but Ballmer felt threatened by a potential successor?
Or what if Sinofsky was just set up to take the fall, since high-level executives at Microsoft must be aware of the difficulties the world is going to face with Windows 8?
And either of these could have to do with Sinofsky, or not. Honestly the whole speculation about what this portends for Microsoft is humorous.
So they fire the assertive asshole and fix none of the other problems that required him to be that way in the first place.... what happens next?
Apple without Jobs may have to wade through the same wilderness of disillusionment, but Microsoft without Sinofsky (assuming you're correct that Sinofsky was Microsoft's "visionary") not only gets the disillusionment, Microsoft starts by tearing itself apart without any sort of pressure to reform or repair the damage.
On the other hand, even assuming Microsoft is fine without Sinofsky, Windows 8 can't be considered nearly as successful as, say, the introduction of the iPhone, simply by the nature of the release: release a new product that requires a lot of change – and _fire_ the leader at the same time? I don't believe even the "best case" can be considered a success.
I used those bloody damn awful Performas, and was part of Schlumberger's migration from Mac to Windows 95.
Then Steve came back and we got all the cool pro stuff [drawing a blank over the toilet seat iMac of course...]