sounds like an oxymoron of a claim.
"Write this code in a way that is readable and maintainable" is another example.
It's almost as though it's not about the Monet.
In the paper I linked they created a benchmark spanning 80 disciplines with tasks that could be checked automatically. So these are necessarily tasks that are tractable for RLVR, trivially you could use performance against the benchmark as a reward function. The performance was still mediocre in everything but programming. And as we're seeing in this article, there is still room for growth in programming.
In general you seem to be reading very literally in some places (taking the statement "AIs aren't good at X" as applying to all AI and perpetually) and very loosely in others (disregarding "easily" as unimportant) and misinterpreting statements you appear to agree with as being in disagreement. I don't think there's a real disagreement here, I think there's a misunderstanding.