If it's a government employee (as it should), it shouldn't be open to fraud and abuse, no. There should be a trail of what happened
PS: I have actually suffered through some of this, badly so, though in an unrelated setting.
It comes back to which system is more robust/mistake-proof and more practically recoverable.
However, I thought more about this and I now agree to your position. Till there is still a significant enough percentage population that is not setup to use the new approaches (digitization/Internet in the example at hand), the older methods need to stick. Meanwhile, assuming the new approaches actually offer more value, there should be an appropriate push for moving the remaining population towards it.