First, after a few years, a new motherboard will probably require a new type of RAM, which can be quite expensive to fully populate.
It's also possible that the new motherboard will not have the same type of peripheral slots as the old motherboard did, requiring you to buy all new peripherals when you upgrade.
Finally, buying a new motherboard will force you to "upgrade" to a new BIOS, like UEFI -- which can bring in a whole host of problems that the old BIOS did not have (such as not easily being able to boot your existing operating system).