The purpose of the paper is to sketch out a field of investigation for social studies by observing cases which contradict the conventional wisdom in that field, as opposed to a rigorous or complete quantitative analysis. I'm sorry if I oversold it by stating why I considered it significant.
I don't think rigor necessitates the use of equations. Ronald Coase's nobel-winning contributions to the field of economics are almost wholly conceptual and devoid of math; at the opposite extreme, over-reliance on Li's Gaussian Copula proved unwise for Wall Street (http://www.wired.com/techbiz/it/magazine/17-03/wp_quant?curr...).