Anti-Portfolio
bvp.com
bvp.com
3 - too expensive (Apollo, Apple, Intel)
3 - bad idea
1 - small market (eBay)
1 - no traction (Lotus)
1 - big incumbent (Compaq)
2 - rookie team (Google, Paypal)
2 - no reason (FedEx, Intuit)
1 didn't understand (StrataCom)
If the reasons are to be trusted (take them with a grain of salt), then they may have learned to i) be more competitive on expensive deals, ii) give "bad ideas" more thought, and iii) not dismiss rookie teams.Paul Graham wrote about this just a few months ago. It's worth a read: http://www.paulgraham.com/swan.html
It was definitely not a slam-dunk idea, and even Benchmark partners felt uneasy about financing an online classifieds site that would be easy to replicate and invite large players to compete in case there was a valid market (Yahoo! indeed made a move at eBay with Yahoo! Actions priced at $0 listing fees, since Yahoo! had other sources of revenue).
While Meg Whitman was being recruited for the CEO role, she browsed the dinky classifieds site and was not super-impressed - Benchmark guys basically bought her and her family air+hotel to at least sell her on California prospects, if not eBay's future.
One of my favorite bits is the aforementioned sell job to get Meg Whitman to join (I believe Meg doesn't the credit she deserves for taking eBay from a tiny startup to a huge business). I remember laughing out loud when the Benchmark folks discuss Meg's kid having a crush on one of the VC's kids. Every little bit counted and they pulled out all the stops.
Love what you guys are doing. If you ever want feedback from someone using/viewing your service from many different fronts, drop me a line.
If anyone's considering Shopify, go for it -- amazing amounts of functionality without any difficulty configuring it, super fast to hit the ground running on a project that needs ecommerce, and tons of power under the hood if you want to expand. One of my favorite services I use.