Should scientists study race and IQ?
nature.com
nature.com
On the other hand, any reported result about relationships (or absence of relationships) between "race" and IQ is inevitably going to be interpreted in terms of #1.
So I'm all for scientists studying genetic correlates of intelligence, but anything that's described as a study of "race and IQ" seems likely to generate more heat than light.
And that's even without getting into the fact that racism (on the one hand) and "political correctness" (on the other) seem likely to introduce bias into the research, how it's written up, whether it gets published, and how the published results get reported to the general public. (Despite all the measures that competent and honest scientists take to reduce the effects of bias.)
People say that a lot - but it's not actually true.
Do you think it's socially important for people to believe that, and to blind themself to differences? Fine, I can accept that. But do not delude yourself into thinking it's actually true.
You can find an interesting piece disagreeing with that view here:
* It's not that ethnic groups don't share common traits it's just the borders are so fuzzy it's going to be hard to narrow down specifics.*
There are plenty of less-mixed people than the example you give. I don't think a studies invovling ethnicity necessarily have to involve every single person in the US, so people without a clear ethnicity don't need to cloud things (though studying someone of mixed ethnicity might be illuminating in some contexts).
Take Halley Berry the "first black woman to be nominated for a Best Actress Academy Award." (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halle_Berry) I would be shocked if she was more than 40% "black" at the genetic level.
It would be an interesting study, but I suspect 60+% of "African Americans" to be at least 25% white in the USA. I suspect if you compared the relative percentage vs (whatever) you would see little change, because social issues tend to swamp most other issues and they tend to identify with black. My first boss was darker than the average African American, but he graduated from Yale and acted more stereotypically "white" than I do.
Other classic examples would be trying to separate Arabs from Jews, Indian from white, Japanese from Chinese, etc. People like to identify with specific groups, but when you look at genetic studies anywhere up to 30% of children in married couples have a different father than they think they do. Culturally Incest is considered evil in part because genetic diversity is positively correlated with survival, but this also extends across cultural and ethic bounds.
PS: Not to mention war / rape and other issues. I heard that the "Black Irish" originated from the destruction of the Spanish armada in 1588. Plenty of people swam to shore and never made it back to Spain.
It proves nothing about the answer, nor is it intended to.
For comparison, a less meaningful question is "are biologically NY people smarter than biologically NJ people?" The question doesn't even make sense since you can't differentiate between NY and NJ people biologically.
As for whether the markers are likely or not to be correlated with interesting phenotypes, I'll wait to see data before guessing about what is likely.
One of the things that shocked me about taking my first Bioinformatics class was how casually the professor talked about race. It seems like the concept of race is well accepted in the field, at least as it denotes large haplogroups of the human species. If you gave me the mitochondrial DNA from an Indian, then I am pretty sure that I could tell you it came from an Indian.
Also, I think well-designed statistical studies would easily meet all your objections.
As to whether or not such studies would be useful - I think they would. A common public policy problem is the disparate performance of students from different racial groups in school. As long as public policy sees racial groups as meaningful, it is probably useful to study them.
I will say that the blank slaters are pretty anxious to maintain the status quo. socialism isn't defensible without assuming neurological uniformity.
The appropriate approach to that chart is to believe our lying eyes, yes? Even with that (relatively) small amount of genetic data, three racial groups are readily apparent, with the Ashkenazi Jews standing out quite drastically.
And since you brought up IQ, it's interesting to note that the Ashkenazi tend to average 10-15 IQ points higher than the rest of Europe. Check out this article from the Journal of Biosocial Science: http://homepage.mac.com/harpend/.Public/AshkenaziIQ.jbiosocs...
We get around with hacks like coffee, and could do much better. SBUX has a $7B market cap.
"Reality is what doesn't go away when you stop believing in it."
That said, of course reality changes, if it didn't we kind of wouldn't have time. (I'm sure Stephen Hawking could put it more eloquently than that.)
Recapture politics to fortify the scientific method: publish all data and source code, publish negative results, aid higher rates of experiment replication and competitive epidemiological studies.
http://www.amazon.com/IQ-Human-Intelligence-N-Mackintosh/dp/...
is the best first book to read about IQ testing. The best second book to read about IQ testing is Flynn's latest book,
http://www.amazon.com/What-Intelligence-Beyond-Flynn-Effect/...
and the best third book on IQ testing to read, after the other two books have given you a conceptual foundation, is Keith Stanovich's latest.
http://www.amazon.com/What-Intelligence-Tests-Miss-Psycholog...
A more complete annotated bibliography
http://learninfreedom.org/iqbooks.html
lists other books, not all from the same point of view.
Of course, knowing which genes will help with task Y may tell you which group is best at task Y. But the reverse is not true and will likely cause discrimination and suboptimal outcomes.