My logical read of the situation is that I end up making fewer overall changes if I end up upgrading a dependency once, not thrice, to a specific version. And the changes are their own source of risk.
That's never a problem until it suddenly is. Company is put at significant risk (courts want to reason by analogy and "engineers skipped maintenance and endangered people" is an easy one) and nobody is to blame since nobody owned the task.
There’s always someone who doesn’t want to take the advice of all the people who’ve been burned because “well it’s never happened to me.” I used to be that someone myself. Until the day it happened to me.