I assume archive.org has done their homework here, but IANAL.
I assume archive.org has done their homework here, but IANAL.
[1] http://www.gutenbergnews.org/20101127/public-domain-day-2011...
The novel and radio play will still be very much under copyright in Europe.
Bad assumption. Archive.org plays fast and loose with copyright law, to quote Brewster Kahle "Who's going to sue a library?"
So there is no Asimov copyright problem as it's based on Campbell's work.
Yet it's presented as Assimov's trilogy. So I don't know what to believe.
Copyright is now 70 years. So, assuming it was published between 1940 and 1942, it effectively felt in public domain hence, inmho ianal, both original story and recorded are now in public domain.
what would happen if I transcribed it?
Also transcribing the radio series would get you the same story, but not the same book.
That means everything. The audio recordings are a derivative work, so the audio"ness" of it is a separate copyrightable/copyrighted work (but the underlying novel itself remains subject to the original copyright). This means that the audio recording is subject to both copyrights unless part of the license given to the creators of the audio work includes a license to redistribute the audio work, which may be the case given that it is a BBC production.
So the Asimov estate has no beef with the BBC, since all licensing was done there, the BBC presumably has no beef with archive.org users, and the Asimov estate has no beef with archive.org users because it is not their place to.
No, that is not what "public domain" means. A public-domain work is still properly attributed to its creator. A person can't take credit for it on the ground that it's in the public domain.
Morally, you're certainly right: it's wrong to take credit for work that is not your own. But legally, I thought this is precisely what "public domain" means. Disney can make a movie out of Snow White without bothering to credit the Brothers Grimm (or their sources) at all, much less needing permission from their heirs. Public domain works can be used by anyone, in any way, for any purpose.
As one example to illustrate this, Creative Commons provides a way to "dedicate work to the public domain". Their human-readable summary says,
"You can copy, modify, distribute and
perform the work, even for commercial
purposes, all without asking permission."
That's pretty much what I was attempting to describe in my previous comment.But honestly, your objection here is very much a side issue. As I already said, the point of my example earlier was to wonder whether someone could hypothetically transcribe the Foundation stories from the audio recording and sell the resulting novels, complete with a cover reading "Isaac Asimov's /Foundation/" (and perhaps with "Edited by J. Smith" in small text somewhere).
It's more typically an issue of academics ethics. Plagiarism is a very serious charge in academia (and to some extent in politics), regardless of the source of the plagiarized material.
As to its being a legal issue, I don't think so, but IANAL. My earlier point was about proper attribution.
> As I already said, the point of my example earlier was to wonder whether someone could hypothetically transcribe the Foundation stories from the audio recording and sell the resulting novels, complete with a cover reading "Isaac Asimov's /Foundation/" (and perhaps with "Edited by J. Smith" in small text somewhere).
I have to say I don't know how that would play out. I guess the example of Shakespeare's plays stands as an example of the freedom one may have in such a case. But that's not plagiarism -- defined as claiming another's work as your own.