The more worrying thing, IMO, are the people paying a bunch of money for Journalism or English Literature degrees.
The more worrying thing, IMO, are the people paying a bunch of money for Journalism or English Literature degrees.
I imagine you should already have a substantial income to qualify even for 185K loan (in most places, it's a mortgage-size loan, with over 2K per month payments), let alone paying 185K in cash, so the improvement should be from the level of people that are already capable of spending 185K - i.e. either having current income substantially higher than, say, level of experienced software developer, or somehow having amassed 185K in cash that they can invest in their education.
This system is what enables American universities to put such high price tags on education, and also what allows the students to actually get approved for such large loans. Almost all of the risk is assumed by the borrower. Even if the graduate cannot find sufficiently gainful employment to repay the loan, the lender still eventually gets a return on their investment. If they were forced to take a loss, that would cause lenders to make their approval processes more stringent, and would limit most students' ability to attend these universities. So it becomes a political issue because no politician wants to be perceived as being responsible for limiting students' access to higher education. The fact is that the risks and costs must be absorbed by someone--under the current system it is the students' future selves. (My personal opinion is that this is a form of modern indentured servitude and should be outlawed.)
Actually, as far as I know most of education loans are now government loans, so there is zero incentive of changing the requirements, and zero incentive to reduce the costs. If these loans are losing money, we can just tax the rich and have more money, can't we?
Student loans are not all government loans, maybe 70% are Federal Student Aid loans. Both FSA loans and subsidized private loans are subsidized by the government, which only means that the government pays the portion of the interest that would be due while the student is still in school. But it does not matter whether the lender is the government or a bank--the loans still carry an interest rate and are still non-dischargeable. The government cannot "just tax the rich" to pay off students' loan balances, the government does not work that way.
They do have a 20 year minimum payment plan and then will forgive the remainder. Not sure if that becomes taxable after the fact.
They also have principal forgiveness plans for government or teaching service.
Source: http://www.irs.gov/Individuals/The-Mortgage-Forgiveness-Debt...
The Stanford MBA's income need not be higher by 185K, for the comparison to be fair. It needs to be higher only by the difference between the cost of Stanford MBA and the other MBA.
We are building a society with an extreme focus on personal wealth. Since we are stuck on a single planet with limited resources, that type civilization will not end well.
The problem is not the focus on personal wealth. The problem is that some people think that if they like doing something, its the reason enough to force other people to pay for it, just because that people have personal wealth and thus by definition are soulless fatcats whose property has to be "redistributed" because it's not fair that their pursuits are profitable and poetry reading is not. This is the real problem we are having right now.
The problem is rather that even with this historically high number of jobs available in history, literature, and so on, the universities are now producing people with degrees in those fields at a much higher rate than there are jobs available. Each faculty member added supports the creation of that many more new degrees in the field every year. Our society currently has a place for n historians (and that's a bigger n than ever before), but there are now also n^2 (or whatever) people with history degrees competing for those slots.
There is a place for professionals in these fields, certainly; but there is not a place for every single person who thinks it'd be fun to be a professional historian. The number of people interested in doing that is just far larger than the number of people our society needs to do that. Not everyone can be an astronaut or a rock star, and being a professional in the liberal arts is not different.